In 1983, a wealthy businessman named Carl Fletcher is kidnapped from his driveway in the nicest part of Long Island, brutalised, held for ransom and then returned to his family.

Carl, his wife and three kids begin the hard work of moving on with their lives, resuming their prized places in the saga of the American dream.

But nearly forty years later, when Carl's mother dies, it becomes clear that perhaps nobody ever got over anything, after all. Carl has spent the ensuing years secretly seeking closure to the matter of his kidnapping, while his wife, Ruth, has spent her potential protecting her husband's emotional health.

Long Island Compromise spans generations of one family’s story, winding through decades of history all the way through to the wild present, dealing along the way with all the mainstays of American Jewish life.

And through it all, it addresses timeless questions about wealth, trauma, the American soul, and the mostly unspoken love and shared experience that unite a family forever.